If watching birds brings you joy and excitement, then you’re really going to enjoy butterfly watching too. These stunning winged insects are jewels on flowers. It’s only natural that we want to attract and feed them—just like we do birds. Being “cold-blooded,” butterflies don’t start flying until mid-morning, after sunning or warming themselves from the air. So, you can bird first AND then watch butterflies. Butterflies can be sensitive to approach, so binoculars or long camera lenses are helpful, but good luck following their erratic flight.
Most of our Pennsylvania butterflies are dependent on flower nectar for nutrition and hydration, although some woodland species use tree sap or rotting fruits. But feeding isn’t their only need. These beautiful winged adults have a purpose to fulfill, and nectar is just their fast-food energy drink for sustenance to achieve their goal—reproduction. Understanding more about their life cycle can help us understand how to attract them.

Swallowtails are a summertime favorite
Life of a Butterfly
Butterflies undergo complete metamorphosis, the biological process of growth in which each stage is vastly different. The four stages are egg, larva (called caterpillar), pupa (called chrysalis), and finally adult. Some species undergo a single generation of this cycle each year, while others have two or three generations, and a few like cabbage butterflies have even more.
When the winged insect emerges from the chrysalis, it’s a full adult. There’s no such thing as baby butterflies—that’s what caterpillars are! The adult life phase is typically a short period, lasting only a few days to a couple of weeks. While it may look like butterflies live a carefree life flitting around on flowers, they are focused on their goal!
First, males need to find females to mate. They do this by patrolling on wing or perching. The male may use pheromones to help attract females. Some males are territorial, defending against any suitor or potential threat that enters his space. Once they find a mate, butterflies have courtships that are fun to watch.
The female’s focus after mating is searching for locations to lay her eggs. It’s critical that she only lay her eggs on plant species that her caterpillars can tolerate—and often they are very picky eaters. It’s fascinating to watch her fly around in search of plants. Using chemical signals, she finds the right vicinity. Then she’ll fly around that area, landing directly on a leaf. Using chemoreceptors in spines on the backs of her legs, she checks for a match. If it’s wrong, she keeps searching. But finding the plant still isn’t enough. Once she finds the right plant, then she searches for an ideal leaf for each egg.

Final stage Eastern Tiger Swallowtail caterpillar silked to a Magnolia leaf

Monarch chrysalis found in nature

American Lady, just eclosed from the chrysalis to the right

Great Spangled Fritillary being attacked by territorial male Pearl Crescent Butterflies

Indian Skippers during courtship - notice the wing fluttering of the male on the left

Wild Indigo skipper laying her egg on her namesake host plant
Butterfly Needs
Host Plants: The most renowned butterfly host plants are native milkweeds for Monarchs. Host plants are where the female lays her eggs. Caterpillars feed mostly on leaves of the host (not nectar). Without the right plant, they can’t survive. While some of our butterfly species have a broad, diverse diet, we have many species like Monarchs that require specific herbaceous or woody plants (shrubs and trees). See the table for host plant examples.
Garden Location: Ideally, adult butterflies will search for nectar in locations of convenience. By including a butterfly’s host plant in your garden, it’s more likely the adults will visit and even hang out for a while to sip nectar. Butterflies prefer spots that are less “tidy” and more natural, because that provides safer cover for retreat and protection. That’s important for caterpillars too, because once they are fully grown, they leave their host plant for a protected location to pupate.
To attract butterflies that don’t feed on nectar, you can offer rotting fruit. Some people make a rotting banana/ yeast brew to attract butterflies, but in my yard, ants devour it too quickly.
Nectar Sources: Most flowering plants will attract at least a couple of butterfly species, but a few are powerhouses. While unscientific, I’ve compiled my best “hits” on native nectar plants (at 20-30+ butterfly species on each of these plants) based on my Pennsylvania photo records:
- Common milkweed (plus swamp and butterfly milkweeds)
- Purple coneflower
- Asters (New England, Smooth, Aromatic)
- Mountain Mint
- Beebalm (especially Monarda fistulosa)
- Yellow coneflowers (Rudbeckias)
- Goldenrods (especially Showy and Blue stem)
- Honorable mention to Joe-Pye as a magnet for Eastern Tiger Swallowtails—and annuals Zinnias, Salvias, and Mexican Sunflower (Tithonia).
You can purchase cultivars of many of these natives that offer gardenesque features like brilliant colors, bigger flowers, double petals, etc. Just beware that they’re selected for human interest, not nectar production. If your goal is to support wildlife, stick to straight-species plants (or trial-tested cultivars).
When planning your garden, add flowers that bloom in spring and fall too. Mid to late fall is a critically important period because butterflies that migrate, including Monarchs and Painted Ladies, are in need of food. So are species that wander outside their normal breeding range. Asters and Goldenrods feed the majority of fall migrants in our yard and are where we find our rarest butterfly visitors.

Cloudless Sulphurs, summer migrants to PA, need Senna family plants for their caterpillars to survive

Great Spangled Fritillary and Delaware Skipper feeding on Common Milkweed nectar

Fall nectar is critical for fall migrant butterflies like Monarchs (and overwintering bees)
How to Support Butterflies
- Provide host plants for caterpillars. Adults search for locations with these plants.
- Provide nectar plants for adults.
- Plant a mix of straight-species flowering native plants (esp for fall)
- Also: rotting fruit /sap (home brew)
- Untidy yards are preferred. Butterflies need shelter for retreat (sleep, rain, escaping predation), and for caterpillar/chrysalis survival.
- No or minimal pesticide use. Pesticides on leaves (or from systemic pesticides that permeate plants) kill caterpillars and harm wildlife that eat them.
- Remove invasive non-natives. Do NOT plant Butterfly Bush (Buddleia), Queen Anne’s Lace, or other invasive plants for nectar. They escape gardens, destroying native butterfly habitat. Note that Butterfly Bush is not the same as Butterfly Weed (Asclepias tuberosa), which is not a weed but IS a native butterfly-attractor in the milkweed genus.


The Red-spotted Purples, like most of our butterflies, have different patterns on their upper and under wing surfaces.
Host Plant Examples
| Butterflies | Host Plants |
| American Painted Lady | Pearly Everlasting, Field Pussytoes |
| Black Swallowtail | Carrot (Apiacieae) family – Golden Alexander, sweet-cicely (parsley, dill, fennel, carrot.) |
| Cabbage White | Mustard (Brassicaceae) family (including invasive species) |
| Eastern Tailed Blue / Gray Hairstreak | Legumes, like clover, bush clovers, tick trefoils |
| Eastern Tiger Swallowtail | Wide range of trees – black cherry, tulip tree, white ash |
| Great Spangled / Meadow Fritillary | Violets |
| Emperors / American Snout | Hackberry |
| Monarch | Milkweeds |
| Mourning Cloak | Wide range of trees – poplars, willows |
| Painted Lady | Over 100 species |
| Pearl Crescent | Asters |
| Question Mark / Eastern Comma | Hackberry, elm, nettle |
| Red Admiral | Nettles |
| Red-banded Hairstreak | Decaying leaves, particularly under sumac |
| Red-Spotted Purple | Black cherry tree |
| Skippers, Various | Grasses – Wild Rye, Purple Top OR sedges |
| Silver Spotted Skipper | Legume generalist – Black Locust |
| Spicebush Swallowtail | Sassafras, spicebush |
| Summer Azure | Flower buds of many families – dogwoods, ninebark |
| Viceroy | Willows, poplars |
| Wild Indigo Duskywing | Wild Indigo, (has adapted to invasive Crown Vetch) |
Resources:
Butterflies of Pennsylvania, a field guide by James L. Monroe & David M. Wright, Publisher: University of Pittsburgh Press 2017
Xerces Native Plants for Pollinators covering Eastern Pennsylvania
Xerces Native Plants for Pollinators covering Western Pennsylvania
Karen Campbell, is a Lehigh Valley Audubon board member and Certified Pollinator Steward. She shares her work on FocusOnNatives.com and Instagram @KarenInNature. Karen provided the content and permission for use of her images for this article.