As fall approaches and leaves decay into their rainbow of reds, yellows, and oranges, they inevitably fall to the ground. While this is what nature intends, we’ve been programmed to view leaves as “litter” that requires prompt shredding and removal.

Leave the Leaves and Save the Stems campaigns are telling us to forgo neat and tidy yards to keep leaves in place. But does it really matter? ABSOLUTELY! It matters for birds and bugs, the plants and soil, the environment, and YOU. And what does this mean in practice? Changing our approach away from traditional gardening practices to being stewards of a naturalized garden takes rethinking our approach as well as considering eco-friendly design changes to the landscape to make the job easier.

Why garden cleanup practices matter

For Birds and Bugs. When we plant annual flowers and native plants, we’re attracting wildlife. But they don’t just drop in for a bite. Many live their entire life cycles in our yards without our even realizing it. By understanding the survival needs of wildlife in our yards, we can better appreciate the critical importance of leaves and stems. The companion article Understanding Wildlife Needs to Support and Protect Them details the food, shelter, and nesting needs of bugs in our yards. It also quantifies the critical role that decaying leaves have in supporting their survival.

Spring migrants like towhees and thrushes rely on arthropods overwintering in the leaves.

For the Plants and Soil. Nutrients and organic matter are recycled naturally from decaying leaves into the soil and back to plants. Remove the leaves, and you interrupt the natural recycling process. Leaves are also a natural mulch, protecting plants through the winter and suppressing undesired weeds in early spring. Purchasing mulch and fertilizer not only costs money, but can be a wrong match for soil and plant needs and may introduce problems (invasive weeds, diseases, residual poisons).

For the Environment and You. By not removing leaves and vegetation, you’re not only helping bugs and birds, you’re reducing your carbon footprint. Instead of releasing methane gas in a landfill or smoke in a burning leaf pile, your leaves decompose into soil that actually locks away carbon. Plus, there is less work for you! Enjoy your extra time by getting out to view fall colors or go birding!

Changing HOW we garden

I learned traditional gardening from my parents in a pristine suburban neighborhood. We planted non-native annuals surrounded by a sea of purchased mulch. Shrubs were pruned to an unchanging size, and we fertilized, mowed, and used herbicides on our lawn. Anything outside that monoculture was removed. We also raked leaves into the street for pickup.

This concept of traditional yard care is ingrained in our culture and the expectation of many of our neighbors. Unfortunately, those traditional landscape practices along with our ever-expanding suburbs and towns are contributing to the rapid reduction in wildlife populations around us, including birds and pollinators. But together, we can reduce that impact and be part of the solution.

Why don’t we see insects in leaves? Because they’re masters of disguise, to hide from predators like birds. This leaf shelter with breathing air holes was built by a caterpillar.
Here’s the pupa shell protected by the leaf, shown after the adult moth emerged.

What it Means to “Naturalize”
I think the simplest way to think about naturalizing our yards and community spaces is first to accept that our yards are part of our local ecology and then strive to make them hospitable for wildlife. How can we do that?

  • Plant more native plants and remove invasive non-natives.
  • Plant in communities using natural aesthetics, allowing plants to grow together and move around. Transition from traditional, rigid garden control to a more natural stewardship.
  • Turn wildlife fear to fascination and appreciation.
  • Transition to an eco-friendly landscape (see this article’s last section).

Naturalized landscapes still require care, particularly in urban and suburban neighborhoods, but done differently. The concept of stewardship, compared to traditional yard maintenance, relies on a balanced clean-up approach to support wildlife while retaining safety and functionality for humans. The following recommendations for fall and spring retain a few familiar maintenance items, but add a few new ways to think about our yards in these seasons.

Fall Recommendations

  • Clear driveways and walkways to prevent slips on wet or frozen leaves.
  • Remove leaves from gutters and storm water drains to prevent clogging.
  • Leave all of the leaves and perennial vegetation in naturalized areas, native plantings, and foundation beds. Stems help retain leaves on windy days and can provide cavities for native bees and other pollinators for overwintering and next season nesting.
  • Turf grasses can withstand some leaves and will benefit from their decomposition.
  • If you have deep leaf piles on lawns or other areas requiring removal, relocate by rake or leaf blower to other areas of your yard where possible, keeping leaf piles modest in height. Mulch (chop) or compost leaves as a last resort. Arthropods in leaves, like Woolly Bear caterpillars, will not survive mulching or composting.
  • Keep leaves on your own property.
  • Keep some dead tree limbs on the ground too; they also provide havens for overwintering insects. We use them as path edges.
  • In vegetable gardens – remove any diseased vegetation, and compost healthy vegetation and fruits.

Spring Tidying Recommendations

  • Tidying should include keeping the leaves and as much plant debris, including stems, in the garden as possible. Stems left at 8-24 inches are best.
  • For neater aesthetics, trim remnant stems. In April, we string trim stems or hand snap and bundle them neatly, retaining them in the garden.
  • If you must remove some of last year’s growth, delay as long as possible, preferably until night temperatures are in the 50s.
  • New planting areas may require some purchased mulch, but over time, leaves will be all you need for mulch and native plant fertilizer.

An Example

This naturalized area next to our garage and along a fence accumulates leaves. Seed heads from fall blooming perennials are bird food in winter.
We leave perennials all winter to hold the leaves in place and let twigs support bees. By March, the leaf load has decomposed significantly.
In one short month to April, this early spring perennial groundcover (Golden Alexanders) has hidden the decaying vegetation.

Additional Stewardship Considerations
Once we stop mowing down everything in our yards, new plants will show up on their own. Many of these are wonderful “free” native plants, but the downside is that invasive plants appear too. In our yard, we’re constantly scouting for invasive plants to remove, and aggressive non-native plants that we deadhead to prevent seed expansion. Spring and fall are the ideal time to scout because plants have different colors or hold their leaves different lengths of time.

Transitioning to an Eco-friendly Landscape

To make future fall clean-up easier, consider these modifications to your yard:

  • Replace turf grass with native herbaceous plant communities as well as shrubs and trees if appropriate.
  • Naturalize more areas in your yard. By prioritizing locations that naturally accumulate leaves, like under trees, along fences, and next to buildings, you reduce your own work.
  • As you naturalize your yard, incorporate design elements to retain a tidy look for neighborhood aesthetics by using mowed grass borders and low plants along the edges.
  • You can keep costs down by using self-seeded plants or dividing herbaceous plants in your yard to expand to new areas such as converting more lawn, a little at a time.

Let your neighbors know that you care about your yard and are intentionally managing for nature – for the birds! Apply for the Pennsylvania Audubon Bird Habitat Recognition Program and receive a yard sign to display. You can learn more about bugs in your leaves at Xerxes, and consider purchasing their Leave the Leaves sign.

Letting nature take its course is not neglect—it’s stewardship! This fall, leave the leaves, and further enhance the nature sanctuary in your yard.

Karen Campbell, a PA Master Naturalist, Certified Pollinator Steward, and member of Lehigh Valley Audubon, provided the content and images for this article. Follow Karen on Instagram @kareninnature or visit her website at focusonnatives.com.